Match date: 18 November 2026.
Final score: Islanders 5, Blue Jackets 1.
The Islanders beat the Blue Jackets 5-1 on 18 November, with M. Schaefer supplying a defenceman’s hat-trick and delivering the response that put the game beyond Columbus after their early third-period push.
Game Story
A. Duclair gave the Islanders their first-period foothold at 19:02, finishing with assists from M. Barzal and T. DeAngelo. The home side carried that 1-0 advantage into the interval.
M. Schaefer doubled it 1:34 into the second period, leaving the Islanders in command through a scoreless remainder of the middle frame. The Blue Jackets found a route back early in the third when Z. Werenski scored at 1:12, assisted by K. Johnson and L. Del Bel Belluz, cutting the margin to one.
That was as close as Columbus came. Schaefer struck again at 7:01, with R. Pulock and Duclair credited with the assists, to restore the two-goal cushion. T. DeAngelo then made it 4-1 at 11:52 from Barzal and M. Maccelli, before Schaefer completed his three-goal night at 16:08, assisted by S. Holmstrom and B. Horvat.
The Islanders finished with a 40-29 edge in shots, while I. Sorokin made 28 saves in a controlled home win.
Turning Point
Z. Werenski’s goal 1:12 into the third period gave the Blue Jackets a live chance at 2-1. M. Schaefer’s second goal, at 7:01, answered it decisively. Rather than allowing Columbus to build on its breakthrough, the Islanders restored their two-goal lead and added two more before the final horn.
Standout Performers
M. Schaefer was the defining figure, scoring at 1:34 of the second period and twice in the third for a hat-trick in 23:23 of ice time. A. Duclair opened the scoring and assisted on Schaefer’s second goal for two points. T. DeAngelo also had a goal and an assist, while M. Barzal supplied two assists. I. Sorokin’s 28 saves limited the Blue Jackets to Z. Werenski’s lone goal.
Tactical Observations
The scoreline was built on the Islanders taking control before the second interval, then responding quickly once the Blue Jackets made it a one-goal game. Their 40 shots created sustained pressure across the full contest, although C. Talbot still made 36 saves. Columbus managed 29 shots, but Sorokin’s work ensured that Werenski’s early-third-period goal did not become the start of a larger comeback. The Islanders’ decisive scoring came at even stages of the game rather than through any stated special-teams advantage.
Coach Mark Comment
A defenceman scoring three goals is unusual enough, but the timing of M. Schaefer’s second was the part that would please any bench. Columbus had finally made the score uncomfortable at 2-1, and the next few minutes could easily have become a long chase. Instead, Schaefer restored the gap before that pressure had time to grow. There is a simple satisfaction in seeing a player produce his biggest moment when the game briefly asks a harder question, and his final goal gave the night a fitting shape.
What It Means
The Islanders turned a narrow third-period lead into a four-goal win, with Schaefer accounting for three of their five goals. Duclair, DeAngelo and Barzal each added two points in a balanced scoring performance behind the hat-trick.
What Comes Next
For the Blue Jackets, the immediate question is how to turn their early third-period breakthrough into a longer spell of pressure. The Islanders, meanwhile, will look to carry the same ability to answer a momentum swing into their next outing.